Pyle and his secretary Gertrude Brincklé seem to have started compiling them in 1910. The first leaves of Volume I feature Pyle’s own handwritten comments about some of his earliest printed things. But then he either lost interest, got distracted or too busy, or left for Italy, so Miss Brincklé must have done the bulk of the finding, trimming, gluing, and annotating. Most of her notes - besides basic bibliographical ones - concern the known owners of particular pictures and if she had posed for any of them. However (as I mentioned in my last post) she also wrote beneath at least a half dozen reproductions the disturbing words, “Destroyed by H.P.” or “Destroyed by Mr. Pyle”.
Now, in the course of my Pyle research I’ve been putting together the skeleton of a very rudimentary catalogue raisonnée (well, a checklist) of his pictures, so it’s always good to know where things have wound up. But it’s never pleasant to learn that certain things have been lost for good. I suppose that if Pyle considered his actions “justifiable picturacide” then we should accept the fate of what he deemed unworthy. Plenty of artists have done what he did, after all... But would if I could go back in time and rescue these from the trash or the furnace or wherever he disposed of them - despite their faults and Pyle’s low opinion.
Anyway, here’s a little memorial gallery for these six gone-but-not-fogotten paintings.
“He climbed the stairs slowly, for he was growing feeble”
From “The Story of Adhelmar” by James Branch Cabell
Harper’s Monthly Magazine, April 1904
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
“Catherine de Vaucelles, in her garden”
From “In Necessity’s Mortar” by James Branch Cabell
Harper’s Monthly Magazine, October 1904
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
“I know thy heart, that thou dost love me well”
From “The King’s Jewel” by James Edmund Dunning
Harper’s Weekly, December 10, 1904
Note: next to Miss Brincklé’s “Destroyed by Mr. Pyle" someone wrote a question mark, so maybe this one escaped the axe, after all?
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
“A man lay prone there, half turned upon his face” also known as “After the Battle”
From “Melicent” by Warwick Deeping
Harper’s Monthly Magazine, January 1905
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
“Sir John shook his spear at the ladies who sneered”
From “Melicent” by Warwick Deeping
Harper’s Monthly Magazine, January 1905
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
“With a cry, Shallum flung up his arms and jumped” also known as “A Leap from the Cliff”
From “An Amazing Belief” by Mrs. Henry Dudeney
Harper’s Monthly Magazine, April 1905
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Ave atque vale!
Posts
